(AI is making me dumber.)
AI has made me incredibly knowledgeable about many things. and as a result, i’m becoming dumber.
that sounds like a contradiction. but the more work i hand to AI, the more i notice that some things don’t come quite as easily anymore. mostly because they don’t have to.
i use AI for writing, to help me make decisions, and for coding. it has made me unfathomably more efficient. lately, though, i’ve been wondering:
what has all that efficiency been costing me?
(i couldn’t have said it better myself.)
like most people, i use AI to take raw ideas and turn them into something that sounds like an address straight from the president’s desk.
(well, most presidents.)
hard conversations that require delicacy get delegated to Lumi, my digital personal assistant. and yes, i am recycling PDA from the 2000s. fight me. rest in peace, PalmPilot.
i find myself running even the simplest messages through ChatGPT for a once-over. sometimes the message i give it already contains the exact message i want to send, just in prompt form.
“create a draft telling George hi.”
hi.
but offloading so much communication has started changing how communication feels when i’m on my own. the words i’m reaching for don’t come quite as easily. concepts i could explain in my sleep become effortful at best and babbling at worst.
(and don’t ask me to spell aynthign.)
(nothing. i choose you.)
Barry Schwartz wrote, “learning to choose is hard. learning to choose well is harder.”
AI was supposed to make choosing easier. instead, it can give me twenty perfectly reasonable answers and leave me less certain than i was when i had none.
the problem isn’t that the robots give me bad options. they give me too many good ones.
indecision. now available at the speed of a supercomputer.
someone once asked how i defined intelligence. after thinking for a second, i said it was the ability to turn raw information gathered throughout life into good decisions.
so, by my own definition, becoming worse at making decisions means becoming less intelligent.
(huh.)
it shows up in real life, too. despite my extensive technical ability, i still haven’t landed on one clear service i want to offer people. ask me to plan a date or a trip itinerary and my brain freezes.
AI isn’t entirely to blame. i already have plenty of good options in my head. but every good option it adds compounds the ones already there, and the paralysis gets worse.
(Claude, who am i?)
by trade, i’m a software engineer. a developer. a coder.
yet i can’t remember the last time i coded.
Copilot started completing my code after i typed a few words. Cursor started creating whole sections for me. now Claude or Codex can complete full projects almost single-handedly.
(single-threadedly? single-promptedly? let’s workshop that.)
AI has made me more efficient. at the same time, the knowledge i used to prop up my identity and my perception of my own intelligence has started to feel less valuable.
my cousin, who would never call herself technical, can now automate a big part of her work. not long ago, that would have required enough programming knowledge to write a script or a macro. i went to a startup pitch competition where someone who couldn’t articulate how their app worked had vibe-coded a full-stack application.
other people becoming more capable doesn’t make me less capable. but while their floor has risen, i’ve quietly stopped practicing many of the skills that built mine.
if Claude, Codex, Lovable, and Replit disappeared overnight, would i still be an engineer?
(i wonder…)
maybe i’m not afraid that everybody can code now. maybe i’m afraid that coding no longer makes me special.
(outsource the work. not yourself.)
so, Josh, what’s the solution?
(i’m glad you didn’t ask.)
i don’t think the answer is to reject AI altogether. i’m not interested in becoming a digital hermit because a chatbot made me forget how to spell. but i do think we need to be more deliberate about what we hand over.
(we’ve been here before.)
when i was a kid, calculators in class were controversial. people worried we would become dependent on them and lose the ability to do simple math by hand.
they were kind of right. most people can still do basic calculations manually, but doing so often feels more like a party trick than a practical alternative to using a calculator.
AI isn’t a perfect comparison. what the calculator did for some math, AI has practically done for everything. still, technology has always made human work easier, and that progress has always come with trade-offs.
as old skills become empty shells, new ones move in like hermit crabs.
(delegate with care.)
i had a conversation with one of my newsletter subscribers who was concerned that AI would make them less sharp. they were intentional about what they did and didn’t allow AI to do for them. i think that’s a really good idea.
my advice was simple: delegate what you would have delegated to another person, and keep practicing the things you want to remain yours.
give the robots the monotonous work you never want to do again. stay sharp in what matters most to you.
i’ll let Lumi draft an email to a customer, but i would never fully delegate my newsletter to her. this is my voice. this is my style. these are my ideas. i want them to stay that way.
(autopilot still needs a captain.)
we’ve had autopilot practically forever. there’s still a captain in the cockpit.
even though AI handles most of the coding portion of my work, i make decisions every day to guide it toward building the right thing. AI can build something that looks amazing at first glance. under even modest scrutiny in real-world conditions, it can fall apart quickly without human intervention.
AI has shown me that the most valuable part of my work was never typing the code. it was deciding what should be built, knowing whether it works, and accepting responsibility when it doesn’t.
the work can be theirs. the decisions are ours. and so are the consequences.
have you noticed AI changing the way you think? what have you gotten better at, and what seems harder than it used to?
i’d love to hear from you in the comments.
tame the robots. make what matters. stay human.
(other places me + the robots roam.)
(let’s keep in touch.)
new essays, straight to your inbox.
published on substack. read the original.
